Brazil still has Sweden in the underground economy

Mirian Leitão.com, O Globo - - 10.7.2013

The good news is that the so-called underground economy has been dropping since 2003, as shown by the data released today by the Brazilian Institute of Competition Ethics (ETCO) and by Ibre / FGV. That year, it was 21% of GDP and, in 2012, it was 16,6%. This last figure represents a reduction of 0,3 points in relation to 2011. The bad news is that in the last two years, the rate of decline in the underground economy, which captures not only informality, but also the production of goods and services reported to the government, which is outside GDP, has been decreasing.

Economist Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho, from Ibre / FGV, explains why this has been happening:

- This slowdown is basically due to the decline in formal hires by the industry and the growth of the service sector, which is labor intensive and very dynamic, but has higher levels of informality than the industry. But in general, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive, as it is necessary to take into account that, even with the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall - he said.

The size of the shadow economy is estimated at more than R $ 730 billion, according to FGV, which is equivalent to Sweden's GDP.

According to the executive chairman of Etco, Roberto Abdenur, despite the government's efforts to create measures to facilitate formalization, membership levels in the commerce and services sectors, where small entrepreneurs predominate, are still very low.

- Since the end of 2012, it has been observed that the growth of the formal labor market has reached its limit due to two major factors: the rigidity of labor laws and the low level of education of the Brazilian - says Abdenur.

Underground economy: the reasons for the slowdown

The good news is that the so-called underground economy has been dropping since 2003, as shown by the data released today by the Brazilian Institute of Competition Ethics (ETCO) and by Ibre / FGV. That year, it was 21% of GDP and, in 2012, it was 16,6%. This last figure represents a reduction of 0,3 points in relation to 2011. The bad news is that in the last two years, the rate of decline in the underground economy, which captures not only informality, but also the production of goods and services reported to the government, which is outside GDP, has been decreasing.

Economist Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho, from Ibre / FGV, explains why this has been happening:

- This slowdown is basically due to the decline in formal hires by the industry and the growth of the service sector, which is labor intensive and very dynamic, but has higher levels of informality than the industry. But in general, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive, as it is necessary to take into account that, even with the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall - he said.

According to the executive chairman of Etco, Roberto Abdenur, despite the government's efforts to create measures to facilitate formalization, membership levels in the commerce and services sectors, where small entrepreneurs predominate, are still very low.

- Since the end of 2012, it has been observed that the growth of the formal labor market has reached its limit due to two major factors: the rigidity of labor laws and the low level of education of the Brazilian - says Abdenur.

ETCO and Ibre / FGV: the underground economy slows down

O Globo Online - Rio de Janeiro / RJ - ECONOMY - 10/07/2013

Despite low GDP growth, the Underground Economy Index continues to decline, albeit at a slower pace than in recent years

The Underground Economy Index (IES), released today by the Brazilian Institute of Competitive Ethics (ETCO) in conjunction with the Brazilian Institute of Economics of the Getulio Vargas Foundation (IBRE / FGV), reached the mark of 16,6% at the end of 2012 , which represents a reduction of 0,3 percentage point in relation to the previous year.

In absolute values, the estimate is that the underground economy in 2012 - the production of goods and services not reported to the government, which is outside the national GDP - has exceeded R $ 730 billion.

Source: IBRE / FGV and ETCO

"In general, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive, as it is necessary to take into account that, even with the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall", says the researcher from IBRE / FGV Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho.

Despite the positive reading, in the last two years there has been a slowdown in the rate of decline of the underground economy in the country. “This slowdown is basically due to the decline in formal contracts by the industry and the growth of the service sector, which is intensive at hand and is very dynamic, but has higher levels of informality than the industry ”, explains Barbosa Filho.

"In spite of the government's effort to create measures that facilitate formalization, especially in the sectors of commerce and services, where small entrepreneurs predominate, membership levels in these sectors are still quite low", evaluates ETCO's Executive President, Roberto Abdenur.

Research recently released by SPC Brasil and the National Confederation of Shopkeepers showed that almost half (49%) of the interviewees do not know what to do to regularize their business. In addition, among those who want to expand the business this year, the majority do not intend to formalize it because they fear bureaucracy, falling income and new costs.

For Roberto Abdenur, “in addition to these issues, it is worth remembering that, since the end of 2012, it is observed that the growth of the formal labor market has reached its limit due to two major factors: the rigidity of labor laws and the low level of Brazilian schooling ”. He points out that “if, on the one hand, softening rigid labor laws and reducing red tape are increasingly essential tasks, investing in education is much more than a goal, it is an obligation for a nation that claims to be strong and positioned among major economies in the world ”.

Informality, in addition to its relationship with organized crime and precarious working relationships, brings direct damage to society, creates an environment of transgression, stimulates opportunistic economic behavior, with a drop in the quality of investment and a reduction in growth potential of the Brazilian economy. In addition, it causes a reduction in government resources for social programs and investments in infrastructure.

FGV: Informal economy reaches minimum in ten years despite Pibinho

O Globo Online - Rio de Janeiro / RJ - ECONOMY - 10/07/2013

RIO - The so-called underground economy, production of goods and services not reported to the government, corresponded to 16,6% of GDP in 2012, the year in which the economy as a whole had an increase of only 0,9%. It is the lowest rate registered for the informal economy since the beginning of the series in 2003 and represents a decrease of 0,3 percentage point in relation to 2011. In values, it totaled R $ 730 billion, according to an estimate released this Wednesday by the Brazilian Institute Competition Ethics (Etco) in conjunction with the Brazilian Institute of Economics of the Getulio Vargas Foundation (Ibre / FGV).

The strong labor market, with the generation of formal jobs, explains this behavior, according to FGV / IBRE Applied Economics researcher Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho.

- Informality falls systematically, even in years of crisis, which means that institutionally we are improving, but the smaller falls are signaling an exhaustion - he says.

Barbosa Filho emphasizes that the signs of job depletion, income and credit this year may impact the next results.

- The economy is no longer helping as before. Credit expansion has stopped, and with that, part of the stimulus to formalize as well. The trend is not continuing. We need institutional change, de-bureaucracy and deregulation of the labor market, although this is highly unlikely to happen.

Research recently released by SPC Brasil and the National Confederation of Shopkeepers showed that almost half (49%) of the interviewees do not know what to do to regularize their business. In addition, among those who want to expand the business this year, the majority do not intend to formalize it because they fear bureaucracy, falling income and new costs.

For Roberto Abdenur, Executive President of ETCO, the formal labor market has reached its limit due to two major factors: the rigidity of labor laws and the low level of education of Brazilians.

- If, on the one hand, softening rigid labor laws and reducing bureaucracy are increasingly essential tasks, investing in education is much more than a goal, it is an obligation for a nation that claims to be strong and positioned among the main economies in the world - he said.

 

Informal economy surpassed R $ 730 billion in 2012, estimates FGV

G1 - Rio de Janeiro / RJ - ECONOMY - 10/07/2013

The Underground Economy Index (HEI) in Brazil, which measures the set of activities of goods and services that are not reported to the government, as occurs in the informal market, fell by 0,3 percentage point in 2012 compared to 2011, to 16,6% of the country's Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

The data were released on Wednesday (10) by the Getúlio Vargas Foundation (FGV) and by the Brazilian Institute of Competitive Ethics (Etco).

Despite the percentage drop, there was growth in absolute value: it is estimated that the underground economy surpassed R $ 730 billion last year, compared to R $ 702 billion in 2011.

According to the entity, the fall of the HEI has been occurring since 2003. That year, the informal economy represented 21% of GDP. But the best in the indicator lost strength. From 2010 to 2011, the HEI decreased 0,8 percentage points.

"In general, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive, as it is necessary to take into account that, even with the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall," he said in a note , FGV / IBRE Applied Economics researcher Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho.

"This slowdown is basically due to the drop in formal hires by the industry and the growth of the service sector, which is labor intensive and very dynamic, but has higher levels of informality than the industry," he explained.

Informality drops only 0,3 pp in 2012

Revista SM - - LATEST NEWS - 10/07/2013

The IES (Underground Economy Index), released today (10/7) by ETCO (Brazilian Institute of Competition Ethics) together with IBRE / FGV (Brazilian Institute of Economics), reached the mark of 16,6% at the end of 2012, which represents a reduction of 0,3 percentage point in relation to the previous year.

In absolute figures, the estimate is that the underground economy in 2012 - the production of goods and services not reported to the government, which is outside the national GDP - has exceeded R $ 730 billion.

“In general, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive, as it is necessary to take into account that, even with the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall”, says Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho, researcher in Applied Economics at FGV / IBRE.

Brazilian economy not included in the GDP account is larger than Denmark

UOL - São Paulo / SP - ECONOMY - 10/07/2013

Matthew Lombardi

From UOL, in São Paulo

The Brazilian “underground” economy, one that is not counted in the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) account, moved in 2012 more than the entire economy of Denmark, according to a study released on Wednesday (10) by the Brazilian Institute of Ethics in Competition (ETCO).

In addition to the informal market, the indicator calculates everything that moves in the country, but is not officially reported to the government. For example, a factory that produces 100 pairs of shoes and declares only 90 to the government, collaborates with 10 pairs for the “underground” economy.

According to the study, the “underground” economy generated R $ 730 billion in 2012, about 16% of the country's Gross Domestic Product. Denmark's economy moved around R $ 715 billion in the same period.

Rate of decline in informality slows

The indicator had a reduction in relation to the percentage of GDP registered in 2011, going from 21% of the country's economy to 16%. However, there was a slowdown in the pace of the decline.

"This slowdown is basically due to the drop in formal hires by the industry and the growth of the service sector, which is labor intensive and very dynamic, but has higher levels of informality than the industry," said the researcher from IBRE / FGV Fernando de Holanda Barbosa Filho, responsible for the research.

The economist points out that, despite the reduction in the rate of decline of the index, the result is still positive. "It is necessary to take into account that, despite the low performance of the economy in the year, informality continues to fall," he says.

Economy grew 0,9% in 2012, the worst year since 2009

The Brazilian economy grew 0,9% in 2012, the worst annual performance since 2009, when it shrank 0,3%. In 2011, there was an increase of 2,7% and, in 2010, 7,5%.

In current values, GDP reached R $ 4,403 trillion in 2012. GDP per capita reached R $ 22.402, remaining practically stable (0,1%) in relation to 2011.

Considering the three sectors of the economy, services was the only one that presented a positive performance in the accumulated in 2012, with an increase of 1,7%. In turn, the industry shrank 0,8% and agriculture fell 2,3%.

UOL - São Paulo / SP - ECONOMY - 10/07/2013